Difference between revisions of "Who Are The Brain Police?"
| (10 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | __NOTOC__ | ||
| + | |||
==Lyrics== | ==Lyrics== | ||
| Line 16: | Line 18: | ||
==Players On This Song== | ==Players On This Song== | ||
[[Freak Out!|FREAK OUT!]] version | [[Freak Out!|FREAK OUT!]] version | ||
| − | * [[Frank Zappa]] - guitar & vocals | + | * [[Biography|Frank Zappa]] - guitar & vocals |
* [[Ray Collins]] - lead vocalist, harmonica, tambourine, finger cymbals, bobby pin & tweezers | * [[Ray Collins]] - lead vocalist, harmonica, tambourine, finger cymbals, bobby pin & tweezers | ||
* [[Jimmy Carl Black]] - drums (also sings in some foreign language) | * [[Jimmy Carl Black]] - drums (also sings in some foreign language) | ||
| Line 22: | Line 24: | ||
* [[Elliot Ingber]] - alternate lead & rhythm guitar with clear white light | * [[Elliot Ingber]] - alternate lead & rhythm guitar with clear white light | ||
[[Disconnected Synapses (BTB)|Disconnected Synapses]] version | [[Disconnected Synapses (BTB)|Disconnected Synapses]] version | ||
| − | * [[Frank Zappa]]- guitar and vocals | + | * [[Biography|Frank Zappa]]- guitar and vocals |
| − | * [[Howard Kaylan]]- vocals | + | * [[Flo & Eddie|Howard Kaylan]]- vocals |
| − | * [[Mark Volman]]- vocals | + | * [[Flo & Eddie|Mark Volman]]- vocals |
* [[Jeff Simmons]] - bass | * [[Jeff Simmons]] - bass | ||
* [[Ian Underwood]] - keyboards | * [[Ian Underwood]] - keyboards | ||
* [[George Duke]]- keyboards | * [[George Duke]]- keyboards | ||
* [[Aynsley Dunbar]] - Drums | * [[Aynsley Dunbar]] - Drums | ||
| + | * [[Jean-Luc Ponty]] - Violin | ||
| − | This version on Disconnected Synapses is different in style and has a style similar to John Lee Hooker's song Boogie Chillin' | + | This version on Disconnected Synapses is different in style and has a style similar to [[John Lee Hooker]]'s song "Boogie Chillin'". |
==Records On Which This Song Has Appeared== | ==Records On Which This Song Has Appeared== | ||
| Line 39: | Line 42: | ||
'''[[:Category:Original Albums|Original Albums]]''' | '''[[:Category:Original Albums|Original Albums]]''' | ||
* [[Freak Out!]] (1966) ~ The Mothers Of Invention | * [[Freak Out!]] (1966) ~ The Mothers Of Invention | ||
| − | * [[The MOFO Project/Object]] (2006) | + | * [[The MOFO Project/Object (Fazedooh)]] (2006) |
* [[The MOFO Project/Object (Deluxe Edition)]] (2006) | * [[The MOFO Project/Object (Deluxe Edition)]] (2006) | ||
'''[[:Category:Beat The Boots|Beat The Boots]]''' | '''[[:Category:Beat The Boots|Beat The Boots]]''' | ||
| Line 46: | Line 49: | ||
* [[Mothermania]] (1969) ~ The Mothers Of Invention | * [[Mothermania]] (1969) ~ The Mothers Of Invention | ||
* [[Panta From Brain Police Meets Frank Zappa]] (1999) ~ The Mothers Of Invention | * [[Panta From Brain Police Meets Frank Zappa]] (1999) ~ The Mothers Of Invention | ||
| + | * [[Understanding America]] | ||
'''[[:Category:Unauthorized Compilations|Unauthorized Compilations]]''' | '''[[:Category:Unauthorized Compilations|Unauthorized Compilations]]''' | ||
* [[Frank Zappa y The Mothers of Invention]] (1972) ~ "¿Quien Es el Cerebro de la Tira?" | * [[Frank Zappa y The Mothers of Invention]] (1972) ~ "¿Quien Es el Cerebro de la Tira?" | ||
| Line 64: | Line 68: | ||
===Tribute & Cover Albums=== | ===Tribute & Cover Albums=== | ||
| − | *Bootleg or Rootleg CD ~ [ | + | *Bootleg or Rootleg CD ~ [https://www.discogs.com/artist/209509-The-Molecules The Molecules] on French label [http://www.amanitarecords.com/label/artists.php Amanita] |
*[[The Ed Palermo Big Band Plays The Music Of Frank Zappa]] ~ [[The Ed Palermo Big Band]] | *[[The Ed Palermo Big Band Plays The Music Of Frank Zappa]] ~ [[The Ed Palermo Big Band]] | ||
| Line 70: | Line 74: | ||
<blockquote>"At five o’clock in the morning someone kept singing this in my mind and made me write it down. I will admit to being frightened when I finally played it out loud and sang the words."</blockquote> | <blockquote>"At five o’clock in the morning someone kept singing this in my mind and made me write it down. I will admit to being frightened when I finally played it out loud and sang the words."</blockquote> | ||
| − | <div align=right>— [[Frank Zappa]], ''[[Freak Out!]]'' liner notes, 1966.</div> | + | <div align=right>— [[Biography|Frank Zappa]], ''[[Freak Out!]]'' liner notes, 1966.</div> |
<blockquote>"'[[Who Are The Brain Police?|Who Are the Brain Police?]]' asks listeners if the music they listen to would cease to bring them pleasure if the packaging and material fetishes surrounding it were to suddenly disappear. It uses the record album as a model, asking what we’d do if the label were to come off and the plastic were to melt. The middle of this tune about attention to decorum rather than substance is interrupted by a snippet of '[[Help, I'm A Rock]]' from later on the album, although the part’s longer here than within its actual piece. This might simply be done to make the song even more eerie, or perhaps to 'jolt the listener out of any comfort brought on by identification with this music,' as [[Kevin Courrier]] writes. This isn’t the last time Frank will play with the listener’s trained impulse to seize on formulaic music; on the [[We're Only In It For The Money|Money]] album, the sound of a phonograph needle jumping out of a catchy song will frequently keep the ear from getting too used to the pleasant hooks."</blockquote> | <blockquote>"'[[Who Are The Brain Police?|Who Are the Brain Police?]]' asks listeners if the music they listen to would cease to bring them pleasure if the packaging and material fetishes surrounding it were to suddenly disappear. It uses the record album as a model, asking what we’d do if the label were to come off and the plastic were to melt. The middle of this tune about attention to decorum rather than substance is interrupted by a snippet of '[[Help, I'm A Rock]]' from later on the album, although the part’s longer here than within its actual piece. This might simply be done to make the song even more eerie, or perhaps to 'jolt the listener out of any comfort brought on by identification with this music,' as [[Kevin Courrier]] writes. This isn’t the last time Frank will play with the listener’s trained impulse to seize on formulaic music; on the [[We're Only In It For The Money|Money]] album, the sound of a phonograph needle jumping out of a catchy song will frequently keep the ear from getting too used to the pleasant hooks."</blockquote> | ||
| Line 76: | Line 80: | ||
<blockquote>"A lot of people police their own brains. They're like citizen soldiers, so to speak. I've seen people who will willingly arrest, try and punish their own brains. Now that's really sad. That's vigilante brain policism. It's not even official, it's like self-imposed. It's hard to pin it down to one central agency when you realize that so many people are willing to do it to themselves. I mean, the people who want to become amateur brain police, their numbers grow every day - people who say to themselves, 'I couldn't possibly consider that', and then spank themselves for even getting that far. So, you don't even need to blame it on a central brain police agency. You've got plenty of people who willingly subject themselves to this self-mutilation."</blockquote> | <blockquote>"A lot of people police their own brains. They're like citizen soldiers, so to speak. I've seen people who will willingly arrest, try and punish their own brains. Now that's really sad. That's vigilante brain policism. It's not even official, it's like self-imposed. It's hard to pin it down to one central agency when you realize that so many people are willing to do it to themselves. I mean, the people who want to become amateur brain police, their numbers grow every day - people who say to themselves, 'I couldn't possibly consider that', and then spank themselves for even getting that far. So, you don't even need to blame it on a central brain police agency. You've got plenty of people who willingly subject themselves to this self-mutilation."</blockquote> | ||
| − | <div align=right>— [[Frank Zappa]], ''[[Interview by Bob Marshall]]'', October 22, 1988.</div> | + | <div align=right>— [[Biography|Frank Zappa]], ''[[Interview by Bob Marshall]]'', October 22, 1988.</div> |
<blockquote><p>FZ: "The heaviest stuff on there is '[[It Can't Happen Here]]' and '[[Who Are The Brain Police?]]' Nobody's penetrated '[[Who Are The Brain Police?|Brain Police]]' - yet."</p><p>FK: "Who are the Brain Police?"</p><p>FZ: "I can't tell you that - it's a religious song. But the ones who say they like '[[Who Are The Brain Police?|Brain Police]]' like it because it's got some screaming and they love it. The ones that like '[[Help, I'm A Rock]]', you know that mumbling part at the end, haven't come to realize what the musical structure of that is. They'll perceive it because it's got some gag lines in it."</p></blockquote> | <blockquote><p>FZ: "The heaviest stuff on there is '[[It Can't Happen Here]]' and '[[Who Are The Brain Police?]]' Nobody's penetrated '[[Who Are The Brain Police?|Brain Police]]' - yet."</p><p>FK: "Who are the Brain Police?"</p><p>FZ: "I can't tell you that - it's a religious song. But the ones who say they like '[[Who Are The Brain Police?|Brain Police]]' like it because it's got some screaming and they love it. The ones that like '[[Help, I'm A Rock]]', you know that mumbling part at the end, haven't come to realize what the musical structure of that is. They'll perceive it because it's got some gag lines in it."</p></blockquote> | ||
| Line 85: | Line 89: | ||
==CC Clues In This Song== | ==CC Clues In This Song== | ||
| + | |||
| + | Mentions [[plastic]] and [[chrome]]. | ||
[[Category:Tracks]] | [[Category:Tracks]] | ||
[[Category:Singles]] | [[Category:Singles]] | ||
[[Category:The Real Frank Zappa Book (The List)]] | [[Category:The Real Frank Zappa Book (The List)]] | ||
Latest revision as of 11:01, 16 November 2021
Lyrics
What will you do if we let you go home,
And the plastic's all melted and so is the chrome?
Who are the brain police?
What will you do when the label comes off,
And the plastic's all melted and the chrome is too soft?
Who are the brain police?
What will you do if the people you knew
Were the plastic that melted and the chromium, too?
Who are the brain police?
Players On This Song
FREAK OUT! version
- Frank Zappa - guitar & vocals
- Ray Collins - lead vocalist, harmonica, tambourine, finger cymbals, bobby pin & tweezers
- Jimmy Carl Black - drums (also sings in some foreign language)
- Roy Estrada - bass & guitarron; boy soprano
- Elliot Ingber - alternate lead & rhythm guitar with clear white light
Disconnected Synapses version
- Frank Zappa- guitar and vocals
- Howard Kaylan- vocals
- Mark Volman- vocals
- Jeff Simmons - bass
- Ian Underwood - keyboards
- George Duke- keyboards
- Aynsley Dunbar - Drums
- Jean-Luc Ponty - Violin
This version on Disconnected Synapses is different in style and has a style similar to John Lee Hooker's song "Boogie Chillin'".
Records On Which This Song Has Appeared
Singles
- Trouble Comin' Every Day (05:50) / Who Are The Brain Police? (03:33) - The Mothers Of Invention (1966)
Zappa Albums & Side Projects
- Freak Out! (1966) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- The MOFO Project/Object (Fazedooh) (2006)
- The MOFO Project/Object (Deluxe Edition) (2006)
- Disconnected Synapses (1992) ~ Frank Zappa & The Mothers
- Mothermania (1969) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- Panta From Brain Police Meets Frank Zappa (1999) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- Understanding America
- Frank Zappa y The Mothers of Invention (1972) ~ "¿Quien Es el Cerebro de la Tira?"
- Pop History Volume 11 (1972) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- Pop History Volume 14 (1972) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- Pop History Volume 6 (1972) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- Pop History Volume 7 (1972) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- Pregnant (1972) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- The Old Masters Box I Sampler (1985) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- The Old Masters, Box I (1985) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- Threesome No. 1 (2002) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- The Supplement Tape (1990) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
- Battle of Eric Burdon & the Animals and the Mothers of Invention (?) ~ The Mothers Of Invention
Tribute & Cover Albums
- Bootleg or Rootleg CD ~ The Molecules on French label Amanita
- The Ed Palermo Big Band Plays The Music Of Frank Zappa ~ The Ed Palermo Big Band
Notes About This Song
"At five o’clock in the morning someone kept singing this in my mind and made me write it down. I will admit to being frightened when I finally played it out loud and sang the words."
"'Who Are the Brain Police?' asks listeners if the music they listen to would cease to bring them pleasure if the packaging and material fetishes surrounding it were to suddenly disappear. It uses the record album as a model, asking what we’d do if the label were to come off and the plastic were to melt. The middle of this tune about attention to decorum rather than substance is interrupted by a snippet of 'Help, I'm A Rock' from later on the album, although the part’s longer here than within its actual piece. This might simply be done to make the song even more eerie, or perhaps to 'jolt the listener out of any comfort brought on by identification with this music,' as Kevin Courrier writes. This isn’t the last time Frank will play with the listener’s trained impulse to seize on formulaic music; on the Money album, the sound of a phonograph needle jumping out of a catchy song will frequently keep the ear from getting too used to the pleasant hooks."
"A lot of people police their own brains. They're like citizen soldiers, so to speak. I've seen people who will willingly arrest, try and punish their own brains. Now that's really sad. That's vigilante brain policism. It's not even official, it's like self-imposed. It's hard to pin it down to one central agency when you realize that so many people are willing to do it to themselves. I mean, the people who want to become amateur brain police, their numbers grow every day - people who say to themselves, 'I couldn't possibly consider that', and then spank themselves for even getting that far. So, you don't even need to blame it on a central brain police agency. You've got plenty of people who willingly subject themselves to this self-mutilation."
FZ: "The heaviest stuff on there is 'It Can't Happen Here' and 'Who Are The Brain Police?' Nobody's penetrated 'Brain Police' - yet."
FK: "Who are the Brain Police?"
FZ: "I can't tell you that - it's a religious song. But the ones who say they like 'Brain Police' like it because it's got some screaming and they love it. The ones that like 'Help, I'm A Rock', you know that mumbling part at the end, haven't come to realize what the musical structure of that is. They'll perceive it because it's got some gag lines in it."
"A free-form nightmare built from mechanical imagery, 'Who Are The Brain Police?' has the strangest instumental break ever recorded – unidentifiable noises superimposed on top of each other including voices babbling indistinguishably, a bass electric guitar being tortured to death and what sounds like a factory steam whistle chorus."
