Difference between revisions of "Talk:Francesco Zappa (The Character)"
m |
|||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
---- | ---- | ||
| − | Hm, I think CC is more appropriate than Supporting Cast, even if there are only two occurances. Reason for this is that as for [[Them Or Us (The Book)]] we are clearly talking about a fictional character, and not the actual composer. | + | Hm, I think '''CC''' is more appropriate than '''Supporting Cast''', even if there are only two occurances. Reason for this is that as for [[Them Or Us (The Book)]] we are clearly talking about a fictional character, and not the actual composer. Of course, this is only to say, I'd prefer CC over Supporting Cast in an either-or situation, which I don't think we have here. |
| − | I'm all for merging [[Francesco Zappa (CC)]] and [[Francesco Zappa (The Character)]]. Seeing as there are several duplicate articles in '''CC''' and '''Them Or Us (The List)''' categories respectively, I wanted to merge two of them (and include the merged article in both categories), but [[User:Duncan|Duncan]] reverted my changes, so I stopped doing that. Unfortunately I | + | I'm all for merging [[Francesco Zappa (CC)]] and [[Francesco Zappa (The Character)]]. Seeing as there are several duplicate articles in '''CC''' and '''Them Or Us (The List)''' categories respectively, I wanted to merge two of them (and include the merged article in both categories), but [[User:Duncan|Duncan]] reverted my changes, so I stopped doing that. Unfortunately I can't seem to remember which article that was... |
--[[User:Fishbrain|Fishbrain]] 04:04, 23 December 2007 (PST) | --[[User:Fishbrain|Fishbrain]] 04:04, 23 December 2007 (PST) | ||
Latest revision as of 04:07, 23 December 2007
Hi
What do you think? Is Francesco Zappa better at home in the Francesco Zappa (CC) section or as Supporting Cast? IMHO there are not enough re-occurances within Zappa's work for Conceptional Continuity. Furthermore I had to split the articles in Francesco Zappa the album and Francesco Zappa (The Character) because Francesco Zappa was clearly no supporting cast.
So either merge the two articles or delete Francesco Zappa (CC)? What do you think?
Propellerkuh 00:09, 23 December 2007 (PST)
Hm, I think CC is more appropriate than Supporting Cast, even if there are only two occurances. Reason for this is that as for Them Or Us (The Book) we are clearly talking about a fictional character, and not the actual composer. Of course, this is only to say, I'd prefer CC over Supporting Cast in an either-or situation, which I don't think we have here.
I'm all for merging Francesco Zappa (CC) and Francesco Zappa (The Character). Seeing as there are several duplicate articles in CC and Them Or Us (The List) categories respectively, I wanted to merge two of them (and include the merged article in both categories), but Duncan reverted my changes, so I stopped doing that. Unfortunately I can't seem to remember which article that was...
--Fishbrain 04:04, 23 December 2007 (PST)
