Difference between revisions of "Talk:That's My Girl"

From Zappa Wiki Jawaka
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
Line 2: Line 2:
 
Do we really want [[That's My Girl|everything]] listed and wikified here in this online encyclopedia, even when it admittedly has no original, authentic, snippet by FZ? I don't want to ruminate ad infinitum. I mean, if I extract a few chords from any FZ-concert, stick "FZ" and some arbitray additional words on the cover and have the impudence to sell that to someone, does that qualify for a new article? I think these kind of items threatens to discredit other content on Wiki Jawaka as unessential. Can we please discuss where to draw a distinctive line?
 
Do we really want [[That's My Girl|everything]] listed and wikified here in this online encyclopedia, even when it admittedly has no original, authentic, snippet by FZ? I don't want to ruminate ad infinitum. I mean, if I extract a few chords from any FZ-concert, stick "FZ" and some arbitray additional words on the cover and have the impudence to sell that to someone, does that qualify for a new article? I think these kind of items threatens to discredit other content on Wiki Jawaka as unessential. Can we please discuss where to draw a distinctive line?
 
:[[User:Propellerkuh|Propellerkuh]] 13:06, 17 February 2008 (PST)
 
:[[User:Propellerkuh|Propellerkuh]] 13:06, 17 February 2008 (PST)
 
Hey neighbor<br>
 
Draw what line? Everything on this album is original Zappa material. Maybe he didn't arrange and edit it, but it is his work. It's a bit of a curio, and I couldn't find much other info on it anyplace else online, so I created a new page for it. Sorry if you take umbrage.
 
[[User:Rocketmartin]]
 

Latest revision as of 22:44, 22 February 2008

Hi friends and neighbors
Do we really want everything listed and wikified here in this online encyclopedia, even when it admittedly has no original, authentic, snippet by FZ? I don't want to ruminate ad infinitum. I mean, if I extract a few chords from any FZ-concert, stick "FZ" and some arbitray additional words on the cover and have the impudence to sell that to someone, does that qualify for a new article? I think these kind of items threatens to discredit other content on Wiki Jawaka as unessential. Can we please discuss where to draw a distinctive line?

Propellerkuh 13:06, 17 February 2008 (PST)